Thursday, April 28, 2011

AI and the Uncanny: Presentation Post

As simulacra of humanity approach that of a real live person we experience an increase in affinity with said simulacra—but only to a point. For instance, we have no problem with a character like C-3P0, because although he behaves like a human he bears only the most passing resemblance to a person. The epitome of the uncanny valley is a corpse, because while it looks just like a living person, it lacks that requisite humanity. The same is true of robots, androids and cinema. Humans like to try and emulate human emotion and expression, and as of now, artificial intelligence is far from perfect, though that won’t stop scientists from trying to obtain “more human than human” perfection. Latest AI scientists seek to program computers (and thus robots) with cognitive thought so that a computer will have the ability to visibly read--and understand--the expressions on the user's face. With a flick of the user's finger or a tightening in his lips, a computer may soon be able to read these motions as "angry," and react accordingly. For some people, advanced technology such as this will be world-breaking, exciting, a new way of approaching our more mechanic counterparts; for others, however, the mere thought of computers with cognitive thought is downright frightening and shocking. The uncanny valley is really an uncanny wall in which those who strive to create a human that is "more human than human" will continuously face a Zeno's paradox situation in which no matter how close an animator or sculptor gets he will never reach perfection.
This might be in part explained by Kristeva’s theory of abjection—that humans are repulsed by those objects which challenge our sense of boundaries and limits. Things which come from the body but are not alive, which are part of oneself but simultaneously not part of oneself, meet this criterion, and according to Kristeva this explains the disgust of a human when viewing spit, dung, or other forms of bodily discharge. Similarly, androids who approach, but do not reach, a human appearance may fall into a gulf which challenges our perceptions of what it is to be human. Androids force us to acknowledge the fact that we are cyborgs, and differ from our machines in degree, not in kind. This terrifying (and liberating) revelation has led to a new late-20th and 21st century conception of intelligence and consciousness as detached from any specific state of matter (such as the human body)—the posthuman is a construct which we use to understand our existence as cyborgs, and to try to reframe the paradigms through which we understand our existence in relation to other beings, both living and mechanical.
That being said, it is also important to realize that while AI is still imperfect, it is constantly improving, and as it continues to improve, it constantly challenges our conception of what it means to be human and blurs the lines between human and computer. In our presentation, we used examples like the computer-generated post-modern essay and the Turing test using the Internet chatbot A.L.I.C.E. to show how difficult it can be to distinguish between human and something else—something robotic, something computer-generated, something virtual, something other. So, if we can’t tell the difference between human and this robotic other, what is the difference, and why does it matter? Maybe there is no difference. Perhaps it is already irrelevant. As Timothy Morton puts it, “The brilliance of Blade Runner, and of Frankenstein, is not so much to point out that artificial life and intelligence are possible, but that human life already is this artificial intelligence.” Maybe that’s the most terrifying thing about the uncanny valley; the closer humans get to being able to successfully replicate what is human, the more our notion of what it means to be human is obliterated.

--Jeffrey, Maria, Amelie, and Holly

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

"Everything is Amazing and Nobody's Happy:" Louis CK on the Modern World and the Eternally Unsatisfied Human Being

Here's a humorous bit on people being ungrateful that our amazing technology can sometimes be... a little less amazing.

Monday, April 25, 2011

Creeptastic.

Funny story... while I was logging into blogger to post this article, Google checked with me to make sure it had my correct phone number. When did I give Google my phone number? ...oh, wait, I have an Android. Yeah, that'll be it.

Friday, April 15, 2011

A Blogga My Own

So I've been working on this blog now. It purports to be on "stories, as long as they're told." Check it out if you want.

http://roundaboutstorytelling.blogspot.com

Thursday, April 14, 2011

Statistical Error in Hikikimori Presentation

In the presentation, I mistakenly said that 10% of the Japanese population were hikikimori. I had gotten this statistic from a Japanese video, but I read it mistakenly. The actual number are thus:

According to psychologist Tamaki Saitō, who first coined the phrase, there may be one million hikikomori in Japan, representing 20% of all male adolescents in Japan, or 1% of the total Japanese population.


From: Saitō, Tamaki. 1998. Shakaiteki Hikikomori (Social Withdrawal). Tokyo: PHP kenkyuujyo.

Sorry for the confusion. It's still a big number, though.

Related news in America:

Neglected child dies while parents play World of Warcraft: http://arstechnica.com/gaming/news/2005/06/547.ars

Teenager goes into convulsions after playing World of Warcraft computer game for 24 hours: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/worldnews/article-1086700/Boy-goes-convulsions-playing-World-Warcraft-24-hours-straight.html#ixzz1JWxgN9eb

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

Broken Heart



My first stop motion attempt.
Snow Patrol, Headlights On Dark Roads

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Simularea and the World of Art

 
 

CaitEmma

Erik Johansson
Erik Johansson


Cole Rise


Cole Rise
Dove Evolution: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXf8fr0Kp3Q
GirlTalk: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6JBAxkZun3s&feature=related

Monday, April 11, 2011

READING FOR TUESDAY APRIL 12

Hey guys,
We were hoping that everyone could take a look at these two short articles before our presentation tomorrow. Both of them are pretty short and straightforward, so please look over them enough to be able to participate in class discussion. We decided to choose an article from Science Daily and a more theoretical article that incorporates Baudrillard's simulacra and has a few references to a few other things we've talked about in class. We chose these reading because our project is dealing with Artificial Intelligence, and we thought that it would be interesting to look at how A.I. can be applied to Baudrillard and the simulacra. A few things that you may want to ask yourself when you are reading: How do androids, cyborgs, and robots (as depicted in the Science Daily article or otherwise) relate back to simulacra as used by Long (and Baudrillard)? How does Long's opening statement that "the truth is meaningless" apply to simulacra and artificial intelligence? How could Long's article be used to dissect Veskler's claim in Science Daily that robots can be used to better understand human problems?

Here is the link to the Science Daily Article:
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2010/12/101230114808.htm

And I'm having trouble getting the link to Long's article to work, but it's short, so I'll just copy + paste it here:
The Stone Door: Rationalism, Baudrillardist simulacra and surrealism
Stefan E. Long
Department of Literature, University of Oregon

1. Neotextual capitalism and Lacanist obscurity

“Truth is meaningless,” says Sontag; however, according to Abian[1] , it is not so much truth that is meaningless, but rather the economy, and subsequent collapse, of truth. But in Foucault’s Pendulum, Eco examines surrealism; in The Aesthetics of Thomas Aquinas, however, he affirms the capitalist paradigm of narrative. The subject is contextualised into a surrealism that includes sexuality as a paradox.

“Sexual identity is part of the dialectic of narrativity,” says Lacan. Thus, if Lacanist obscurity holds, the works of Eco are reminiscent of Koons. Lyotard uses the term ‘pretextual dialectic theory’ to denote a self-justifying whole.

But de Selby[2] implies that we have to choose between Lacanist obscurity and subcultural Marxism. In Ulysses, Joyce reiterates patriarchial predialectic theory; in A Portrait of the Artist As a Young Man, although, he deconstructs surrealism.

However, Bataille promotes the use of capitalist desituationism to analyse and read sexual identity. A number of discourses concerning surrealism may be discovered.

But the premise of Lacanist obscurity holds that consciousness is capable of significance. Foucault suggests the use of surrealism to deconstruct sexism.

2. Expressions of defining characteristic

“Class is impossible,” says Debord; however, according to Finnis[3] , it is not so much class that is impossible, but rather the genre of class. Thus, the subject is interpolated into a capitalist desituationism that includes language as a reality. Sartre promotes the use of the postcapitalist paradigm of discourse to modify sexual identity.

If one examines surrealism, one is faced with a choice: either reject cultural theory or conclude that expression must come from communication, but only if Derrida’s model of Lacanist obscurity is valid; if that is not the case, Bataille’s model of capitalist desituationism is one of “subcapitalist rationalism”, and hence intrinsically used in the service of capitalism. It could be said that the subject is contextualised into a conceptualist materialism that includes truth as a whole. The characteristic theme of the works of Joyce is the dialectic, and some would say the absurdity, of postcultural class.

“Sexual identity is part of the failure of consciousness,” says Foucault. Thus, the example of surrealism depicted in Joyce’s Dubliners is also evident in A Portrait of the Artist As a Young Man, although in a more mythopoetical sense. Bataille suggests the use of structuralist subcapitalist theory to attack sexism.

If one examines surrealism, one is faced with a choice: either accept textual objectivism or conclude that the goal of the participant is deconstruction. It could be said that if Lacanist obscurity holds, we have to choose between capitalist desituationism and the postconstructive paradigm of narrative. Derrida uses the term ‘surrealism’ to denote the role of the artist as reader.

“Society is fundamentally dead,” says Debord. But the primary theme of de Selby’s[4] critique of the dialectic paradigm of discourse is the common ground between sexual identity and reality. The premise of capitalist desituationism implies that academe is capable of significant form.

The characteristic theme of the works of Joyce is the collapse, and subsequent futility, of postcapitalist sexual identity. Therefore, Lyotard promotes the use of surrealism to analyse and challenge class. La Fournier[5] suggests that we have to choose between Lacanist obscurity and precapitalist textual theory.

However, an abundance of discourses concerning the bridge between society and class exist. Surrealism states that expression is created by the collective unconscious.

It could be said that Debord uses the term ‘postdialectic construction’ to denote the rubicon, and some would say the economy, of cultural sexual identity. If surrealism holds, we have to choose between the substructuralist paradigm of reality and textual desituationism.

Therefore, Sartre suggests the use of surrealism to attack outmoded, colonialist perceptions of society. The subject is interpolated into a precapitalist conceptual theory that includes narrativity as a totality.

It could be said that Geoffrey[6] holds that the works of Joyce are not postmodern. Lyotard promotes the use of Lacanist obscurity to read truth.

Therefore, Sartre uses the term ‘Derridaist reading’ to denote the difference between society and class. If surrealism holds, we have to choose between capitalist desituationism and the subcapitalist paradigm of consensus.

But the subject is contextualised into a Lacanist obscurity that includes narrativity as a reality. The main theme of Abian’s[7] model of capitalist desituationism is not deconstruction, as surrealism suggests, but subdeconstruction.

In a sense, many theories concerning postcultural feminism may be found. The primary theme of the works of Joyce is a self-sufficient totality.

But Reicher[8] states that we have to choose between Lacanist obscurity and predeconstructivist narrative. The subject is interpolated into a dialectic paradigm of context that includes sexuality as a reality.

3. Surrealism and neocapitalist theory

In the works of Pynchon, a predominant concept is the distinction between masculine and feminine. However, in Vineland, Pynchon affirms capitalist desituationism; in Mason & Dixon he reiterates Baudrillardist hyperreality. If surrealism holds, we have to choose between neocapitalist theory and cultural discourse.

But Debord suggests the use of surrealism to challenge hierarchy. La Fournier[9] holds that we have to choose between neocapitalist theory and dialectic narrative.

It could be said that the main theme of Prinn’s[10] essay on capitalist desituationism is not, in fact, construction, but preconstruction. If surrealism holds, the works of Fellini are postmodern.

1. Abian, C. W. S. ed. (1976) Capitalist desituationism in the works of Eco. Panic Button Books

2. de Selby, E. J. (1995) The Absurdity of Language: Surrealism in the works of Joyce. University of Georgia Press

3. Finnis, G. F. L. ed. (1989) Structuralist desublimation, surrealism and rationalism. Loompanics

4. de Selby, T. H. (1994) Reassessing Expressionism: Surrealism and capitalist desituationism. Panic Button Books

5. la Fournier, K. ed. (1977) Capitalist desituationism and surrealism. Harvard University Press

6. Geoffrey, N. P. L. (1993) Discourses of Genre: Surrealism in the works of Joyce. University of Michigan Press

7. Abian, P. ed. (1974) Surrealism and capitalist desituationism. O’Reilly & Associates

8. Reicher, Y. G. B. (1998) Dialectic Discourses: Capitalist desituationism in the works of Pynchon. Oxford University Press

9. la Fournier, P. ed. (1974) Capitalist desituationism and surrealism. Schlangekraft

10. Prinn, Z. U. H. (1986) The Collapse of Narrative: Capitalist desituationism in the works of Fellini. Yale University Press

Thursday, April 7, 2011

David Bordwell Says DVD's Have Made Movies More Like Books

In the following blog post/essay (slippery nomenclature! whee!), renowned film critic David Bordwell (anybody who's taken a class with Dr. McCormack knows about him) asks the question: To what extent has the DVD changed viewing habits and movie storytelling?

He goes on to entertain and defend the notion that the DVD made a movie more like a book.

I think this is appropriate for the blog because he is referring to that point that McLuhan made, "all media work us over completely," a point that we've also been discussing in the classroom.

So now, ironically, we read movies more like books; or, according to Bordwell, we have the ability to do so. How, in light of his insight, should we think about the notion of seeing media as something that "progress?" I'll leave you guys with a quote and then a link to the article:

http://www.davidbordwell.net/blog/2007/05/13/new-media-and-old-storytelling/

This sounds odd, because we think of digital media as replacing print. Yet consider the similarities. You can read a book any way you please, skimming or skipping, forward or backward. You can read the chapters, or even the sentences, in any order you choose. You can dwell on a particular page, paragraph, or phrase for as long as you like. You can go back and reread passages you’ve read before, and you can jump ahead to the ending. You can put the book down at a particular point and return to it an hour or a year later; the bookmark is the ultimate pause command.



Monday, April 4, 2011

More from Vancouver

Continuing from the other day, on my panel at ACLA one speaker discussed Calvino's "If On A Winter's Night A Traveler," and another speaker talked about Borges's "Library of Babel" in relation to new media memes. (My talk, of course, was on airports and the temporality of air travel.)

As I mentioned in my last post, the panel I was on was called "Defining the Postcontemporary"—and I was reminded that Brian Massumi's book "Parables for the Virtual" is one of the books in the series "Post-contemporary Interventions" that Duke University Press publishes. So, even in this loosely topical way, the panel was grappling with similar questions as our class, about what defines the present, and how we might move into a (speculative) future, without nostalgia for past forms and with open minds toward different social practices...

It was just exciting and affirming how many intersections there were, between the conference panel and our class. It made me feel really good about what we have been doing all year: even when our subject seems endlessly expansive or recklessly sloppy, even when we seem to be quibbling about fine points that simultaneously have bewildering scope, we've been on the leading edge of difficult conversations about traditional forms of knowledge and new media technologies. The conference panel made me proud of what we are doing—proud of how you all have been exploring these subjects and making connections across our complex (if all too slippery) contemporary field.

Friday, April 1, 2011

Virtually in Vancouver

I'm thinking about you all as I attend the American Comparative Literature Association conference in Vancouver this weekend...I wish you could hear how relevant our class is to current studies!

On my panel alone, which is entitled "Defining the Postcontemporary," people brought up such topics as:

"Gatekeepers"

New media memes like the "doubles guy"

Does e-reading changes the production of literature?

How is the internet an 'institution'?

I'll post again after my panel reconvenes today, as I'm sure more themes that resonate with our class are bound to come up...

Gmail Motion

Check it out!

Thursday, March 31, 2011

Just a small note

So I was looking around in the app world today to see what worthless free apps I could find (they're always my favorite). I ended up with one called Grass. You can guess what it is just by the title, and yes it really is that worthless and boring. You are literally staring at a patch of grass that will move a little bit when you touch it. That's it. Nothing more to it. I just thought it would comfort everyone to know that there are worse apps than the Guru Meditation out there.

Another thing: why does this app really exist? Are there so many people in this world that never get a chance to play with actual grass so they need it on their iPad? How could anybody ever think that this could in any way simulate touching actual grass???

Thursday, March 24, 2011

Orwell versus Huxley

http://forwearemany.files.wordpress.com/2010/01/huxley-vs-orwell.jpg

Hyper Hyper Text and a Flood

Greetings from a friend of a friends in a bed I've never seen with a computer thats not mine.

Alright, so I was pretty excited about tomorrow's reading (or rather today since its 3:00 am).  However, to preface this early morning post: the Carrollton Hall dorms flooded around 11:00pm.  On my floor, 6th to be exsact, down the hall there was a accident causing the fire sprinklers to go off.  The entire right side of the building is just short of destroyed. Ceiling ties, carpeting, walls, and rooms are done for. (If you think this is dramatic then you would be right. It was a scene out of Titanic.)

Students were bustling outside the emergency exits, alarms were flaring, and uniformed persons were in command.  My favorite part was when, during evacuation, I passed the room that the accident occured and saw water quickly flood out into the hallway. Yikes. Even better was seeing the side of the building from the outside seep with water and spill in mass off the brick and flood the walkways.

Chaos.
Yes. Chaos.
[Never let go Jack!]
Quite the chaos - oh - and the same type of chaos in say... "The Medium is the Message."

Alright, so I'm not sure how my life will be in the next few days so I figured I would post. Janelle told me I would like McLuhan piece since I am a huge fan of "The House of Leaves." Good call.  MM was pretty entertaining and definitely made 5 pages in the Moleskin.

So here we go...
I thought the break down of each social construct, such as family or education, was a great aspect in the beginning of the book. Along side the images filled with irony and propaganda, it was a intriguing rhetoric that McLuhan used.  Certainly (and especially since most people know of my passion for photography) the images were all at once odd, beautiful, haunting, and amiss, dare I say, simulacras? This in and of itself was a fabulous chaotic decision on McLuhan's part.  He was able to utilize photos that not only stimulated the events or people within the image, but also stimulate the sense of chaos while reading.  I found myself asking where would he take me next?

Next, the quotes held their own in the piece as well.  While the images and photography somewhat scream for attention, the quotes were dominant. For example, in a world of chaos, what would you say if asked, "Who are you?" Touche McLuhan.

Now, beyond the images and the curiously inserted quotes, the context of what McLuhan was saying follow through with what the class has been talking about. I'm sure most can agree that there was plenty of references to Digital Natives and Digital Immigrants.  Furthermore, McLuhan uses this tension of generations to explain that there is indeed a language barrier going on.  This language barrier, extending out of the electric circuit (EC), is what causes the discrepancies and fissures between those who are comfortable inside the circuit and those who are not.  Because correct me if I'm wrong, but McLuhan believes that whether one acknowledges it or not, we are all already in the EC.

Living in the EC is at once daunting and demanding.  We are daunted by the effects of EC through media, but it cannot escape it because it demands that we participate in it.  This is why Digital Immigrants, from a McLuhanian point of view, are simultaneously afraid and already within the EC.  It is quite like McLuhan's notion of the ear.  We are forever unable to turn off hearing, unless we are deaf.  Unlike the eye, there is no lid to shut it.  We have no way of shut ourselves from EC.
 [The ear is to noise as we are to media.] 

However, what happens when we embrace EC?  We cannot be released from it - our society is marinated in the technological age - but if we can come accept it what would that mean?  Because of EC McLuhan says that children are growing up faster.  True.  Because of EC our news comes immediately. True. --> Everything is fast, fast, fast.  

Great, well what does that mean? 

If I'm Tim Morton I'd say we are in the Mesh. In a way thats very true.  To a certain extent we are Meshing.  However, a distinction needs to be made.  Media isn't creating a Mesh for us.  They are not necessarily creating these "connections".  Yes, EC allows for such connections, but media and EC are perhaps only illuminating the Mesh and/or this interconnectedness.  EC is the medium through which our solidarity is revealed.  

This is what I can do at a close run to 4:00am now.  (My apologies.) Its be a hard day, if I make to Bobet it I'll be in my PJs, wish me luck, and pray to the dorm room gods. 

C

P.S. The iPad unfortunately got left behind. 

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

Google Books deal revoked

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-12827031

This is relevant to the class' interests.

Friday, March 18, 2011

YACHT

http://vimeo.com/5860685

So, this link is to the music video for musicians/performance artists/digital media enthusiasts/whatever YACHT. It's basically an experiment in symbols without context and I thought people in this class would find it interesting. In many ways I think it's very similar to the Heavy Industries piece in that it ellicts an emotional response which is devoid of any concrete meaning.

Sunday, March 6, 2011

Chapter 1

You are the Reader--the controller of the iPad. Settle back, stretch out your legs. Perhaps you enjoy shifting positions--your attention flits from one thing to another (homework to New Orleans cuisine to Stanley Fish's latest blog post), and your ever-changing position mimics your thought process. Bed. Carpeted floor. Wooden chair by the TV. You turn off the TV. Place the remote control on the chair's armrest, change your mind, lay it on the floor.

Relax. Sunlight filters into the room from the part in the curtains--too dim. Adjust the brightness of the screen. Better. You press the Home Button on the iPad with your index finger, type in your password (0523--your birthday), and go to Settings. You sit back, throw your legs over the armrest and finally breathe. Relax. Anticipate.

You have found the ideal position: the iPad is propped up against your thighs. There is a small smear in the upper-left hand corner of the screen. You attempt to ignore it as you go on the Kindle App to read. The smear catches your attention; you sigh, tug on the long sleeve of your shirt, click the iPad's screen off, and rub at the mark. Your sleeve leaves a trail of streaks across the screen. You become obsessed. You press your tongue against the cotton of your sleeve--the sleeve is now damp, the ocean blue now a navy--and you return to the screen, scrubbing, scrubbing, scrubbing--the streaks will come off--and then you stop to admire your handiwork. There are wet streaks and dust has collected in the crevices of your iPad cover.

Your ideal position has now been compromised. You decide--with an emphatic nod to yourself--that the streaks will not bother you. (You remember that your obsession with precision and perfection led you to snapping at anyone who dog-eared your printed books...You sigh in relief at the mere thought that books are now electronically produced and you no longer have to worry about broken spines and dog-eared pages and food stains).

Willing yourself to ignore the dust, you tap the Amazon Kindle app, and your library immediately loads. Swiping your index finger from right to left across the screen, you scroll through your library. You stop at your modest collection of Pynchon novels. With the tap of your middle finger you choose Gravity's Rainbow. You have read this before (twice), but you decide that there must be something you have missed in the past. You debate whether to go through your bookmarks and notes to spark some sort of argument in your head, but you ultimately decide on starting at the beginning of the e-book: your location is 1%, 1-11.

You begin reading "Chapter 1 Beyond the Zero." You skip over the quote by Wernher von Braun and onto the first sentence. "A screaming comes across the sky. It has happened before, but there is nothing to compare it to now."
The words are too familiar. You are having second thoughts about your selection.

It's not that you expect anything in particular from this text—you have learned that no entity is complete within itself, that no text will satisfy your craving for the ultimate text. There is no text without a sequel, an update; the ever-permeable nature of digital technology demands the constant evolution of textuality. You have learned not to expect a feeling of fulfillment at the end of a novel. You have learned to expect the novel's second edition to replace the first, with or without your consent. You have learned to save your favorite passages in a word document--one never knows when they will be altered by some unseen force. Presumably this force knows what it's doing--it may be presumptuous of you to save a scrap of text which the author wishes to alter--and you feel a pang of guilt, but still you save scraps and phrases which mean something to you, trying to preserve the relics of last year, last month, last minute.

You decide abandon your rereading of Pynchon in favor of browsing the Internet for a suggestion of something new. You open Safari and open one of your favorite blogs. Lucky for you, this blogger has just published a review of the new "digital translation" of Calvino's novel, If on a winter's night a traveler. Modernized For The Digital Era! the advertisements proclaim proudly. An Ode to the Collaborative Force which is Intertextuality! Experience the Inevitable Thrill of Translation! You weren't sure what this meant, exactly, but the phrase was somehow compelling. So you opened your Kindle app and went to the bookstore. Good for you.

In the bookstore, you glance briefly at the Amazon recommendations. Your brother recently bought his textbooks on your account, and as a result your most recent recommendations are of varied content--textbooks on nuclear physics, Wodehouse novels, an interactive graphic novel by someone you've never heard of but you think your younger sister mentioned him, once. You pass these by. You have a limited amount of time. You can't go buying every book in the damn store--it would surpass the memory capacity of your iPad, for one thing.

You type Calvino's name in the search bar and allow yourself to be directed to the latest edition of If on a winter's night a traveler. A cheerful prompt informs you that others who have bought this item have also bought other novels by Calvino. You do not want other novels by Calvino. You select If on a winter's night a traveler, and you buy it.

Once you've tapped the purchase button, the iPad screen flashes to your electronic library. A small, somewhat transparent digital cover of If On a Winter's Night a Traveler appears on your shelf next to The King James Bible (free edition) and Reading Borges After Benjamin (which you bought in hopes of doing some extra reading for your Reading W/ the Digital Human class but have yet to finish). You patiently watch the little bar signifying the progress of the download of your book fill with blue. The progress bar vanishes and the cover becomes opaque.

You are now ready to begin reading Italo Calvino's If on a Winter's Night a Traveler.

Thursday, March 3, 2011

Final Project Proposal

*This group had several ideas and this is one of the prospective ones.  There may be some slight changes if and when consultation with a professor is necessary. 

ERIK JOANSSON, photography and retouch artist

In a digitized world, there are several types of mutative or evolutionary social changes.  These changes can be considered both mutative and evolutionary.  This fluctuation in society is what is arguably bringing progress concerning many cultural facets.
We have talked about change social facets with music digitizing, books digitizing, to the classroom setting digitizing.  However, what happens when something as "human" as Art is digitizing?
Today, there are many forms of digital art; there is anything from digital photography, digital to stop-motion films, digital/ electronic music and the like.
Our group would like to explore the world of Art and how it is mutating and evolving from being a separate entity from the technological world to how it is embracing it and relying on it.  We will do this through an exploration of contemporary artists, different mediums with devices like the iPad, and how the Art is being presented with blogs and showcase websites.

Cait, Kalee, Joshua

Japanese Digital Culture

Japanese Digital Culture. The aura of the Japanese culture and its connection to digital media is already loaded with
content. We are going to research how a completely different culture has adopted the digital sphere, and the different
factors that have made a contribution. Japanese industries continue to dominate internationally in digital hardware
such as cameras and displays, but has fared less well in content and services. Although certain areas, like anime,
have become popular in younger cultures, they still represent subcultural niche products taht are not major
export industries for Japan. Some commentators call this the Galapagos effect, and it will be interesting to see what
factors led to the rise fo the dominance of certain digital "species."
Japan can also serve as a great example for the dangers of technology. Although it may be easy to say, "no, we're not
like them," part of our presentation would just be about asking the question: are we really not like them? If not, are we not even close?

Final Project: Chris Rolando and Elle

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

The Reality of the Digital Human

Final Project Proposal:
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is a concept that is almost as old as science-fiction itself, and our fascination with AI has only increased since its first forays into popular culture. Movies such as I, Robot and Blade Runner have shifted our attention from a mere possibility to a real threat to our reality. As a society, however, it remains to be seen if our issue with Singularity or AI or even Cognitive Robots is a matter of uncanniness. Will our asinine fascination with propelling our technologies towards these different concepts come to an abrupt stop when we are face to face with a thinking machine? Have we, in fact, already come face to face with such a machine? When do concepts such as Singularity, AI, and Cognitive Robots become too uncanny? Do these concepts expose the mechanics of human thought, or can the mechanics of human thought be brought to bear on modern technological developments? In our project, we wish to not only present these issues to the class, but to also decipher and expand upon the phrase "digital human" in an attempt to come to terms with our new reality--a reality, simultaneously liberating, alluring, and terrifying, in which thought is not by definition the exclusive domain of the homo sapien.
Tentative reading list:
Improving Cognition in Computers (US News)
New Cognitive Robotics Lab Tests Theories of Human Thought (Science Daily)
The Singularity: Humanity's Last Invention? (NPR)
Response to The Singularity: Humanity's Last Invention
I, Algorithm (New Scientist)
A Manifesto for Cyborgs (Donna Haraway)

By: Amelie Daigle, Maria Pinheiro, Jeffery Muir, and Holly Combs

Individuality of the Masses/Final Project

Our final presentation will be focused on how we implement "the individual" and aspects of technology with our digital interactions. We will use three different, well-known programs to indicate how technology has been able to become programmed to learn from and in some ways, capture aspects of humanity in the forms of "personalized programming." By using the technology we interact with everyday, programming can effectively learn from and use our own online choices to determine personalities; in a way, personalized programming is a tool in which digital culture could effectively teach technology how to understand and possibly even replicate human taste and personality. The digital media that we interact with on a daily basis is effective because we have programmed it to our individual tastes- but learning the individuality of the masses leaves us with this question: have our programming devices programmed us?

Andrew, Jonas, Terra

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Ipad Dos

So, tomorrow Apple is unveiling the Ipad 2. http://gizmodo.com/#!5770645/next-weeks-apple-event-what-to-expect has the details if anyone else is interested(and a link to the live coverage that will happen tomorrow at 1:00PM).

Saturday, February 26, 2011

Thursday, February 24, 2011

Jeffrey's Midterm

Using Guru Meditation I am continuously reminded of N. Katherine Hayles How We Became Posthuman. In particular I think of the passage, "The posthuman subject is an amalgam, a collection of heterogenous components, a material-informational entity whose boundaries undergo continuous construction and reconstruction." This app foregrounds our subjectivity in a disembodied yogi. We are the floating yogi. More than just an avatar that we control in this game he (she, it, ?) is the digital representation of our heightened consciousness. It is meant to be a visual presentation of our ability to be mindfulness. Later in the same section of Hayles she cites deLeuze and Guattari and their concept of a "body without organs" which brings to mind Donna Haraway's Manifesto for Cyborgs. Guru Meditation is our meditating agent that desires our conscious engagement with a meditative state. It demands its form of meditation in order to function. Otherwise it is simply a figure sitting in a dark place. There is no way of forcing the app to show us what it will do when we obey it's needs, namely sitting still and quiet, except to comply.
Guru Meditation also fits the article "What is an app?" perfectly. Of course Bogost both wrote the article and "wrote" the app so it would stand to reason that they would coincide. Using the Guru Meditation app I think about the dictionary definition that Bogost alters to fit the actual app and not just the word. It is hard to imagine what the not-slanged and not-shortened version of this application would be, but it is easy to see how it has slanged and shortened the practice of meditation. It seems very apropos of the zen buddhist practice of running meditation. In his information section on the app Bogost imagines people using it on the bus or in a crowded place and engaging in mediation on the fly. Whereas meditation has traditionally been a practice of becoming and then remaining still, Guru Meditation condenses this. It demands immediate stillness and then encourages you to best your previous records for focus.
I am above all else frustrated by this app. I see meditation as something that you cannot do wrong. Guru Meditation on the other hand demands strict adherence to its way of being. I find myself not letting go and becoming still but increasing in agitation until I give up. In fact during today's experience with it I felt, for the first time, that it actually did reflect my mindfulness at the end. Something went awry and my app entered a sort of schizophrenic loop between the opening screen, the all black screen with the figure, and the guru on his mat. It cycled through this repeatedly while buzzing a static tone. I thought "yes, this is in fact a reflection of my state of relaxation." A constant attempt to enter a meditative state that is constantly being drawn back out to general awareness only to attempt to dive back in, with the same results each time.


I have an app called Gilt. It is an iPad app for an online clothing store that sells designer clothing and goods at discounted prices. It also has a section, Jetsetter, in which it is possible to book lavish hotel accommodations at high end resorts around the world. I find it fascinating because it is an app designed to improve upon the experience of shopping a website which in turn was designed to improve upon or at least simulate and/or replace the experience of shopping in a store.
Removing the website from the equation however it is curious to see what has happened. The app is on the third level of the simulacra. It is very really founded on the model and aims at total control. It maintains the "cart" of the real store and the "departments" to separate goods but it offers the user a seemingly all seeing and all accessible interface to them. It is founded on a concept of shopping to which there is no original. Even the department store, were there to be a brick and mortar Gilt somewhere, is founded on a fallacious idea of the marketplace. In fact the fact that Gilt does not exist as an actual place is indicative of the level of simulacra on which this app operates. It is meant to be a representation of a thing that does not exist in reality. It is a cybernetic game in which users shop a store that is not real. However, the experience of shopping Gilt influences our concept of how we shop in reality. We want the real world to reflect our ability to have unbridled access to goods like we do online. In a very real sense the experience of shopping online recreates an ideal for which there is no origin. It is a "desperate rehallucinating of the past" in which the "real" experience of shopping can never surpass the model because this real was "only the pretext for the model."
On the other hand these images of goods are indicative of the first order of simulacra. The photographs are signifiers of the actual goods. They grasp toward reality and the real object.

Holly Combs Midterm Pt. 2

Barthes has 7 conditions explaining what "Text" is to him, and I'm going to go through each one, looking at the Facebook app on my iPad in order to see where it falls on the plain of "work" and "text."
1.) Text is not a defined object, cannot be separated from work, a "methodological field" vs. something concrete, held in the language vs. held in the hand
Okay, so Facebook is definitely not a concrete object. It is held entirely in computer code language and whatever language users choose to post on their profiles. If Facebook is a text, I would not know how to go about separating it from the "work" because I'm unsure what the work could possibly be. Perhaps, if someone compiled a book entirely of Facebook statuses or Facebook notes, that would be a work, whereas Facebook would go on existing as a text.
2.) Text does not stop w/ (good) literature, not a hierarchy, cannot be classified, always paradoxical, limits rules of enunciation
It kind of makes me giggle thinking that "good" literature has any place in Facebook, and yet it must. Of the millions of people who use Facebook, some of them must be influenced by "good" literature and must post ideas founded somewhere in "good" literature. Actually, there are millions of Facebook profiles dedicated solely to "good" literature. For example, I am a fan of the David Foster Wallace page on Facebook and a fan of Brief Interviews with Hideous Men. After the billions of misspelled and slanged statuses that people regularly post, I don't think that anyone would argue that Facebook stops at (good) literature. And yet, there is nothing hierarchical about the posts on Facebook. Is Robert Bell's Facebook better than mine because he has 900 friends and I only have 50? No, there is no hierarchical advantage to having more friends. Is Robert Bell's Facebook better than mine because his statuses contain well-thought out ideas communicated in multi-syllabic words and mine usually only contain the lyrics to a song I'm listening to? No, again no hierarchical value. Like many digital mediums that exist today, the text that is Facebook cannot be classified in in its entirety according to literary genre. However, the app store does easily classify the Facebook app as a "social" or "social networking" app.
3.) Text structured but decentered, no closure, serial movement of dislocations, overlappings, variations
Currently Facebook has no center and no closure. I thought at first, the "center" might be the profile screen or the homepage, but then, I realized that screen is different for every person who logs on. As of now, there is no "closure" or end to Facebook in sight. Sure, the sight may close down someday, but when that happens, it won't be the same as the closure provided by a work. If Facebook stops running, there will be nothing to look back on, no closing the cover of the book, the way that their is with a work. As for the notion of serial movement, I think this is one of the places that the term text is most applicable to Facebook. Facebook is ever-changing because people are constantly posting new ideas, information, etc. on their profiles, and new profiles are being created all the time. There may be 4 different Facebook pages for the same band or event or even the same person, and the information that people post may in some ways overlap.
4.)Text is plural/has plurality of meaning, it is like a cloth, the text can be itself only in its difference
For every user, the Facebook homescreen looks different because they are connected to different people, pages, and events. The Facebook experience differs from person to person, though some experiences may be similar. Depending on who you are, who you're friends with, what pages you follow, and when you log on, the Facebook experience can be completely altered.
5.) The text has no father figure, text=network, no respect owed to the author, author can only visit the text as a guest
As I previously mentioned, the Apple App Store, classifies Facebook as a "social networking" tool. By definition, Facebook is a network. It is a web of profiles linked together by comments, likes, pokes, messages, and other posts. Perhaps Mark Zukerberg is the founder of Facebook, but his control over what people post on Facebook is limited at this point. This is not to say that it is totally absent. Facebook gatekeepers do exist in order to ensure that users do not post anything "offensive" on their profiles.
6.) Work=object of consumption, text=activity, something to be played with
Facebooking is definitely an activity. It is a verb; it is something that people do. Users spend hours logged into Facebook chatting with their friends, updating their profiles, and posting things on friends walls. But isn't Facebook an object of consumption as well? Why this social networking site over any of the other ones? And while users are Facebooking, aren't they also taking in their friends' profiles and taking in the ads on the side of the screen?
7.) Work=pleasure of consumption, cannot be rewritten; text=inseparable from enjoyment, achieves transparency of social relations, all language circulates freely
I'm not sure where Facebook falls in the topic of enjoyment, as most Facebook users claim to hate the site while spending hours on it. However, visiting Facebook is a choice, and I'm going to argue that people would not freely choose to get on Facebook if they did not somehow feel that life would be less enjoyable if they did not have a profile. Obviously, social relations are transparent on Facebook. When I log in, my homepage shows me who has recently become friends with who and what my friends have posted on each other's walls. Also, all of my friends and their comments to me are displayed on my profile for anyone to see.
After this exercise, I feel that Facebook does not fit neatly into Barthes' critical framework in terms of his distinction between "work" and "text." Though, the Facebook app seems to be more controlled and tangible than Barthes' "text," it seems to be more text than work due to its classification as network which is constantly changing and which creates different experiences from user to user.

Midterm

Part one:
While playing the guru meditation app, I was very quickly frustrated.  First I was stuck on a dark screen with the weird, blobby guru telling me I was too loud every time I sniffled. Then when I finally got to some scenery, I guess I wasn't still enough for the picky little guru because he sent me back to square one 3 times. It was only at the very end of the seven minutes that I even got the clock to start. The entire time I felt this bizarre anger towards the little guru.  I was trying to interact with him, trying to follow the rules of his game; but he was essentially ignoring me. Instead I was left beating on his door begging him to start floating so I would at least have something to look at.
It was, admittedly, a pretty annoying 7 minutes. I wasn't relaxed at all.  I definitely feel more 'meditated' reading a book than trying to please the guru with my balance skills.  At the same time, I kept thinking about Marc Prensky's article on digital natives and digital immigrants. Which one of them would enjoy this game? Is it one that involves deep attention or hyper attention? Does it even involve attention? In his article, Prensky discusses the differences between legacy content and future content in the educational system.  Which one does guru fit into?  Should i even be trying to label it as either of these?
I just can't figure out where to situate this app. Is it an app made modern but calling back to the deep attention of the past? Or is it a modern game just trying to be original? Is it even a modern game? I guess by the standards that it involves a touch screen and sound sensitivity it is modern, but the idea for this app was born with some of the very first video games. The fact that it's a meditation app is only an homage to the very old meditation board.  
Perhaps Bathes has an explanation for my lack of definitiveness.  In 'The Death of the Author,' he talks about how the "explanation of a work is always sought in the man or woman who produced it" and says that "once the Author is removed, the claim to decipher a text becomes quite futile." I know that, in literature, we have not seen the death of the author.  But maybe Barthes was right.  Maybe the death of the author has come to us in the form of the app.  We don't know who is behind these things.  I don't even know who made the app I'm using now and it's never really troubled me.  I can interact with this app or my weather.com app without worry or concern about who is behind it.  But the more that I think About, the more I begin to feel like my iPad is full of    anonymous people.  
All of these apps can be read as texts.  But these these texts are different from books, magazines or movies.  We have experienced, through the iPad and other things like it, the "birth of the reader," as Barthes calls it.  There is literally no interaction with any sort of authorship in the app world.  There is no call for it.  So what about guru makes me feel unsettled? Why doesn't feel like guru needs an author?
Perhaps it is because guru really does call back to an older time.  But what would the author for an app be like anyway? Has there ever been an instance where there was an 'author' for an app? Maybe I'm even more of a digital immigrant than I thought. 

Part two:
The app I find most fascinating (I'm serious) is the app store.  I go there every day. I like to see what apps are in, what apps are out, what apps are free, what new, unnecessary thing I can do next on my iPad.  It feels like a really bizarre version of going to Forever 21. There's so much for so little and it's so overwhelming how many options I have.  So looking at Baudrillard's "Simulacra and Science Fiction," what order of the simulacra is this app? Is it natural? Well, no.  I really don't think the app store is naturally occurring.  I believe that the app store is simulacra of the second order.  It is "productive, productivist, founded on energy.". There is nothing new, original, or beyond ordinary about the app store.  While it "corresponds science fiction," in that it is truly a manifestation of the immense bounds technology has taken, it is not among the complete other and beyond that the third order identifies with. Perhaps the apps themselves are members of the third order, but the app store is simply the iPad version of any normal store.  It's format is not original.
Perhaps if the app store featured some really awesome way for me to enter in all of my interests and it would tell me apps that I like.  As it is, I search for "PDF reader" in the search bar and that's about as good as it gets.  It doesn't even do suggested apps, which amazon or barnes and noble will do for books, movies, etc.  The app store is merely a "mechanical robot machine," as Baudrillard characterizes the second order.  It does not have any sort of momentum or original power.  It is simply the iPad version of Forever 21, complete with a sales rack.  

Amelie's Midterm

(posted for Amelie by proxy)

Part I

An interesting assumption which would seem to be implicit in the creation of the Guru Meditation app would be that the spiritual (or transcendent) experience of meditation is one which requires translation. The existence of Guru Meditation as an app implies that our culture, which, as Prensky points out, has become increasingly geared towards the digital native (with education, an institution widely assumed to be among the most liberal, being one of the institutions which has had the most difficulty adjusting), is no longer capable of a self-contained and ideally unaided activity such as meditation without a prosthetic device which exists to monitor us and tell us if we are "meditating correctly". The developer claims that the app removes one from the cell phone, because one cannot simultaneously play guru meditation and check one's text messages, but what the app ultimately achieves is reinforcement of the idea of virtuality discussed in How We Became Posthuman.

In the app information, the developer explains that Guru Meditation was not first conceived as an app which would "keep score" or "track your progress", ideas which seem antithetical to the traditional conception of meditation as an entirely self-contained activity; however, even before virtuality had achieved its current state of technical advancement, Guru Meditation did not merely function as a calming graphic pattern, such as the color-changing nightlight I had when I was small. Rather, it existed to provide feedback, to make meditation into something you could "win"--in using Guru Meditation, one asks a machine for spiritual validation which it cannot possibly give, given the limitations of the hardware. This phenomenon is not limited to Guru Meditation--Wii Fit cannot actually tell whether you are running or rhythmically shaking a controller, nor can it tell you if your posture is incorrect when you do push-ups. It can only tell you what it knows--that you are putting such-and-such an amount of weight on a balance board, or shaking the controller at such-and-such a rate. But because I, as a so-called digital native, have become so finely attuned to the concept of virtuality--the machine sees all--I shift my weight to acquiesce to the demands of the on-screen instructor, even when I believe that it has very little to do with the actual point of the excercise. Similarly, while playing Guru Meditation I was continually seized with a desire to meditate the way I do in yoga class--lotus position, thumb and index finger together, three remaining fingers extended, gaze drifting gently toward the tip of my nose--but I was being monitored, and these were not the rules of the game. Interestingly, it might be easier to "succeed" at Guru Meditation not by meditating but by focusing on the little guy on my screen--in fact, I'm almost certain I'd receive more positive feedback. But there's something troubling about my reliance on mechanated virtual feedback, the way I have invested a part of my ego in the machine's verdict.


Part II

Baudrillard defines the third order of simulacra as "Simulacra of simulation, founded on information, the model, the cybernetic game - total operationality, hyperreality, aim of total control." To me, nothing fits this description quite so neatly as Google Maps and its corresponding app.

A founding principle of Google Maps is that the space in which we operate is limited, and it can be known, at least on a representational level, through a pantographic shift. First there was the fantastic, the maps labelled with "here be dragons"; this was followed by an overwhelming sense of wonder as the enormity of space became evident, and it loomed overhead more enormous and miraculous than any dragon could possibly have been--and this was the realm of Baudrillard's second order of simulacra, a distinctly modernist idea of endless expansion, limitless possibilty. In many ways these worldviews still persist--we build larger and more elaborate telescopes, still, and we survey starstuff with something of the old fascination--but most "progress" currently occurs on the front of the third order of simulacra, that of Google Maps.

Google Maps' concern is not expansion. Google Maps does not strive to cover the largest possible area--it is concerned with "total operationality", and aims to represent the space in which we operate on a daily basis. It is not an outward expansion but an increase in informational density which concerns Google Maps. Information must be collected on as small a scale as possible--the goal, after all, is to be able to zoom in. Every street must be labelled, every building and its purpose must be documented. "We can no longer imagine any other universe", because Google has mapped ours so perfectly. In a world which is so pantographically manipulable, there are no dragons anymore.

(edited by Amelie for clarity [read: typos])

Midterm

Part One:

Can computers think?  It seems a pertinent question to ask while playing Guru Meditation on the iPad.  The iPad, in this particular case, acts as a mediator between the player and the App; it seems to safe to say that some people may believe that the Guru Meditation App forces the iPad to "think," but this is not the case.  A slight jerk of the hand, and the little green bar--so tantalizing to the player because it is infinitely unattainable--disappears completely.  The App thus believes that the player has lost his concentration.  But this is cannot be further from the truth.  

Searle, in his article "Can Computers Think?", argues that in order for a computer--a machine--to think, it must have the knowledge as to why something occurs.  He uses the example of computer programmers creating a program in which the computer simulates understanding Chinese symbols; the computer is able to answer questions with Chinese symbols because it searches through its databases for a relevant and "appropriate" answer.  However, the computer does not "think," it simply rattles off the information that has been programmed for it.  Searle describes the computer as having "syntax, but not semantics" (671).  In short, the computer can respond with Chinese symbols because that is what it has been programmed to do, but it cannot formulate a conversation or comprehend what it has said--in a way, the Chinese symbols experiment demonstrates that while a computer can perform to exceedingly high standards, it is not able to explain the *why*.

As such, the same can be said for the Guru Meditation App.  The App does not "think," but only performs.  It acts solely on the motions of the player's hands.  Perhaps the player has managed to wipe his brain of any and all thoughts--which, according the App's Inspiration page, that is what the App is intended for--but perhaps he has naturally shaky hands?  Guru Meditation would promptly end the player's attempt and make him start over again.  Much like the computer with the Chinese symbols, Guru Meditation only understands the programming, but does not take into account the why's or how's or any of the other issues that may play a hand in the game.

The Guru Meditation App also functions as a reproduction of the reality of meditating.  In Benjamin's "The Work of Art," he explains that art is always being reproduced throughout the centuries.  Although Benjamin speaks of films and statues or the like in his article, meditating is simply a different form of art, one which applies to his argument.  The process of reproduction takes away from the original and loses its uniqueness.  That is not to say that the reproduction, of say, the statue of Venus, is not as appealing, but there is something to say about the original--to use Benjamin's vocabulary, the original is "natural."  As such, Guru Meditation is a reproduction of actually meditating; it is a simulation (a program) that creates the illusion of peace because in reality, the player is much more focused with not moving his hands than losing focus completely.  

Part Two:

The Kindle App, and the e-books that can be then bought from Amazon, is a form of the third order of Baudrillard's simulacra.  The third order of the simulacra, in short, is the hyperreal, it is the "simulacra of simulation, founded on information, the model, the cybernetic game--total operationality, hyperreality, and total control" (1).  Perhaps it may help to back up a little: if Kindle (or, let us be more specific, the e-book) is the third simulacra then that means that the printed book must then be of the second order--the model, the imitation of the "natural" (the first order).  

But what is the "natural?"  Baudrillard describes the "natural" to be, in a way, God, or at least a person's imitation of it.  In this particular case, we can perhaps substitute "Author" for "God."  The second order, the printed book, seeks to make a Utopia of the Author (unless we are speaking of Barthes, who claims that we should separate authorship from reading completely).  It is the "real" model, meaning that one can find a book in a bookstore or a grocery mart.  It has been mass-produced and is therefore a reproduction.  However, the third simulacra takes the simulation a step further, a simulacra of a simulacra, if you will.  For a simpler example, let us look at the infamous bagel vs. mini-bagel scenario.  The bagel has been mass-produced, it has become the "ideal" in both shape and form (i.e the printed book has become the ideal because it is what a person recognizes); however, the mini-bagel is not a replication of the standard bagel, but rather a hyperreal version of it, a new version.  The same can be said for the e-book.  

The e-book is intangible; it exists solely in an alternate plane.  The App displays the e-book to appear as the printed book might--it simulates turning pages and text against the back screen, but it is not a printed book.  This can be seen in the simplest of manners: locations rather than page numbers, changes in font, the mere fact that a reader can purchase a book and have it in his library in under ten seconds.  Moreover, the concept of the "library" is also changed, formatted to appear as a real bookcase might (if all the books faced forward, that is).  The Kindle's library is a simulation, an imitation, of a real library; and Amazon's Kindle Store is also a simulation, an imitation, a simulacra, of Barnes&Noble or Borders or any other bookstore.  The e-book (and the Kindle App as a result) is the mini-bagel: it is passed forward as a simulation of the printed book (the standard bagel), when in fact, it should instead be viewed entirely as its own entity.

In addition, the e-book can also be viewed as the third order of the simulacra in a different light.  Baudrillard explains that science fiction (the third order) has altered and changed over the years because the discovery of  Earth has already been completed--in fiction then, one must push past that and create other worlds to show a way of "otherworldliness."  The same can be said for the Kindle App, and also, the e-book.  Since the sixteenth-century, the printed book has been tweaked and altered and praised; for 600 years, it has been the way in which people read.  However, Baudrillard would claim that the progression to the e-book and online reading has been done in much the same way that science fiction has moved to alternate universes.  We have used (and perhaps abused) the printed book, the model of the "natural," and we have now moved onto the hyperreal, or, the third simulacra.  As such, the Kindle App and its subsequent parts (the e-book) is a simulacra of the printed book/bookstore, the production.

Midterm

Guru Meditation and Estrangement

In his blog post, "What is an app?," Ian Bogost gives a critical analysis of this new apple-generated phenomenon. Saying that the complete software-suite experience is being replaced by the divided experience of individual apps, he says: "the days of the software system are giving way to a new era of individual units, each purpose-built for a specific function... Or just as often, for no function at all." what does this mean, that there is no function to the app? Certainly the "Pages" app fulfills (however unsatisfyingly) the word-processor function, and Keynote makes Powerpoints look older than they ever looked. Yet Bogost may be onto something here. The perfect app to examine in light of this quotation is the Guru Meditation (GM).

Ostensibly a meditation app, GM leaves many of its users confused, dazed, or indifferent. It consists in holding the iPhone (or any iThing) in a specific way, sitting still so that a small pixelated guru may float in the air for as long a time as possible. The graphics in the app as austere at best, recalling the earliest days of the atari system, further increasing one's non-excitement for the app. That is, we are used to apps with good graphics(especially game apps), but this app goes the opposite way, purposefully. The creator of the app writes: "An earnest meditation game would have to reject graphical sensuality in favor of simplicity and austerity." So now we see: the game looks to challenge our expectations that we may further enter in a meditative state, by providing the graphical palate that is analogous in the game world to the austere background of a silent, undecorated room. But is that all it does?

The GM forces you to be still, and if possible, silent. And suddenly you realize: here you are, looking at an iPad for an indefinite period of time. To an outsider, you look dumb, if not worse. This is similar to how I felt when I "played" with the app during the seven minutes in class. I looked around me and saw fifteen stupid students doing a stupid thing. That's what it at first seemed like. Then I realized that most of the developed world is in this kind of state for long periods of their days: staring lazily at a computer while they perform a function that, as the GM aims, gets to be invisible with repeated use (think about how one gets used to the words on the keyboard).

This reminded me of Walter Benjamin's analysis of the film actor in his essay "The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction." he says that the film actor, when performing, is estranged from his public, yet, in a metaphorical sense, "with" them: "while he stands before the apparatus, the screen actor knows that in the end he is confronting the public." This strange feeling is akin to one seeing oneself in the mirror, Benjamin explains. Communicating to an audience of potentially millions of people, the actor feels desperately alone.

And I think this is the inadvertent effect of the Guru Meditation app, because it reminds us of the fact that, at a most basic level, we spend most of our days staring at a screen, alone, communicating with the world, precisely by snatching the world away from us and leaving us with a meaningless pixelated guru.

And thus this app paradoxically points at perhaps not the uselessness of apps that Bogost referred to earlier, but certainly at the consequences of the estrangement from the world that occurs when the human can access it from a device in his hands.

Am I saying that this is negative? Not necessarily; but we must consider that in Japan, there is a special term for people who literally do not leave their homes because they are totally plugged in to the cyber-world--people who are horrified of actually confronting other people, much like the fat people in Pixar's Wall-E. The term is hikikomori, which means "withdrawal."

Thus, in its uselessness, the uselessness that Bogost pointed at, the GM points us to the loneliness at Benjamin described in his essay some fifty years ago. What should be our reaction?
I'm not exactly sure, but we should be cautious.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Barthes and the Gateway App

Some apps perform the function of being gateways to other sources. The NPR app gives you access to radio bits given throughout the day. The WWOZ app gives you straight access to the WWOZ radio waves, and the NY Times Editor's Choice app gives you a selection of the "best" or most important articles in a given day. It is at this very literal level that these apps resist definition, or, as Roland Barthes said, "cannot be thought of as defined objects." He further explains this by saying that the text must be thought of as "an activity, a production." Rather than a concrete thing that "occupies book-space," the text is a "methodological field." This gives way to an interpretation of text as event and not as substance. And indeed, these Gateway apps, like the NY times app, share this quality at a very literal level. Depending on when you click on the NY Times app, the words that you see on the IPad's screen (or field) change--the product of "the Editor's" decision to show you one thing rather than another. The Gateway app, like the text, is always changing. Not only in the sense expained above, but also in the fact that it is constantly being updated (a quality that all apps share). It is thus that this kind of app is always "without closure"---again, in a very literal way.

Let us return to Barthes's notion of the "methodological field." This is a very tricky, elusive concept, by its very definition--that is, Barthes picked this term because he was precisely trying to point at the text's elusiveness in contrast with the work's concrete quality. I propose that the iPad's screen can serve as an analogy to the elusiveness of the text. Moreover, it can serve as an analogy to the mobility, the constant movement, of the human mind. The mind is fragile and ephemeral, and precisely one of the functions of writing is to preserve memory, that the mind may not completely erase an experience. But the iPad is quick to forget. The NY Times app field lives strictly in the now of the news, only reporting what is current. And the NY Times app does not have an archive where you can access last week's or even yesterday's article; it lives strictly in the now that the "editor" gives you. And this makes the iPad, when performing the NY Times app, an analogy for the mind.

Midterm

Guru Meditation and Estrangement

In his blog post, "What is an app?," Ian Bogost gives a critical analysis of this new apple-generated phenomenon. Saying that the complete software-suite experience is being replaced by the divided experience of individual apps, he says: "the days of the software system are giving way to a new era of individual units, each purpose-built for a specific function... Or just as often, for no function at all." what does this mean, that there is no function to the app? Certainly the "Pages" app fulfills (however unsatisfyingly) the word-processor function, and Keynote makes Powerpoints look older than they ever looked. Yet Bogost may be onto something here. The perfect app to examine in light of this quotation is the Guru Meditation (GM).
Ostensibly a meditation app, GM leaves many of its users confused, dazed, or indifferent. It consists in holding the iPhone (or any iThing) in a specific way, sitting still so that a small pixelated guru may float in the air for as long a time as possible. The graphics in the app as austere at best, recalling the earliest days of the atari system, further increasing one's non-excitement for the app. That is, we are used to apps with good graphics(especially game apps), but this app goes the opposite way, purposefully. The creator of the app writes: "An earnest meditation game would have to reject graphical sensuality in favor of simplicity and austerity." So now we see: the game looks to challenge our expectations that we may further enter in a meditative state, by providing the graphical palate that is analogous in the game world to the austere background of a silent, undecorated room. But is that all it does?
The GM forces you to be still, and if possible, silent. And suddenly you realize: here you are, looking at an iPad for an indefinite period of time. To an outsider, you look dumb, if not worse. This is similar to how I felt when I "played" with the app during the seven minutes in class. I looked around me and saw fifteen stupid students doing a stupid thing. That's what it at first seemed like. Then I realized that most of the developed world is in this kind of state for long periods of their days: staring lazily at a computer while they perform a function that, as the GM aims, gets to be invisible with repeated use (think about how one gets used to the words on the keyboard).
This reminded me of Walter Benjamin's analysis of the film actor in his essay "The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction." he says that the film actor, when performing, is estranged from his public, yet, in a metaphorical sense, "with" them: "while he stands before the apparatus, the screen actor knows that in the end he is confronting the public." This strange feeling is akin to one seeing oneself in the mirror, Benjamin explains. Communicating to an audience of potentially millions of people, the actor feels desperately alone.
And I think this is the inadvertent effect of the Guru Meditation app, because it reminds us of the fact that, at a most basic level, we spend most of our days staring at a screen, alone, communicating with the world, precisely by snatching the world away from us and leaving us with a meaningless pixelated guru.
And thus this app paradoxically points at perhaps not the uselessness of apps that Bogost referred to earlier, but certainly at the consequences of the estrangement from the world that occurs when the human can access it from a device in his hands.
Am I saying that this is negative? Not necessarily; but we must consider that in Japan, there is a special term for people who literally do not leave their homes because they are totally plugged in to the cyber-world--people who are horrified of actually confronting other people, much like the fat people in Pixar's Wall-E. The term is hikikomori, which means "withdrawal."
Thus, in its uselessness, the uselessness that Bogost pointed at, the GM points us to the loneliness at Benjamin described in his essay some fifty years ago. What should be our reaction?
I'm not exactly sure, but we should be cautious.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Barthes and the Gateway App

Some apps perform the function of being gateways to other sources. The NPR app gives you access to radio bits given throughout the day. The WWOZ app gives you straight access to the WWOZ radio waves, and the NY Times Editor's Choice app gives you a selection of the "best" or most important articles in a given day. It is at this very literal level that these apps resist definition, or, as Roland Barthes said, "cannot be thought of as defined objects." He further explains this by saying that the text must be thought of as "an activity, a production;" rather than a concrete thing that "occupies book-space," a "methodological field." This gives way to an interpretation of text as event and not as substance. And indeed, these Gateway apps, like the NY times app, share this quality at a very literal level. Depending on when you click on the NY Times app, the words that you see on the IPad's screen (or field) change--the product of "the Editor's" decision to show you one thing rather than another. The Gateway app, like the text, is always changing. Not only in the sense expained above, but also in the fact that it is constantly being updated (a quality that all apps share). It is thus that this kind of app is always "without closure"---again, in a very literal way.

Let us return to Barthes's notion of the "methodological field." This is a very tricky, elusive concept, by its very definition--that is, Barthes picked this term because he was precisely trying to point at the text's elusiveness in contrast with the work's concrete quality. I propose that the iPad's screen can serve as an analogy to the elusiveness of the text. Moreover, it can serve as an analogy to the mobility, the constant movement, of the human mind. The mind is fragile and ephemeral, and precisely one of the functions of writing is to preserve memory, that the mind may not completely erase an experience. But the iPad is quick to forget. The NY Times app field lives strictly in the now of the news, only reporting what is current. And the NY Times app does not have an archive where you can access last week's or even yesterday's article; it lives strictly in the now that the "editor" gives you. And this makes the iPad, when performing the NY Times app, an analogy for the mind.

So is the NY Times app a text? If we follow the words of Barthes, then it most certainly can be construed as one.

Cait Emma Midterm Examination

Part 1:
Ian Bogost's Guru Meditation app exemplifies the ideological changes and cultural shifts that our society is undergoing.  It is a prime example of how the way we think, understand, and relate to the world is now through the lens of new media and technology.  The Guru Meditation app shows this lens as it is an activity which reinvents an "original" activity many already participate in.  Meditation, with all of it's stereotypical associations, is more or less an activity done without the assistance of technology. However, with Bogost's app the act of meditation is transformed out of it's traditional box (as we see it) and inverts it as completely dependent on technology - by the use of the iPad. This simulation, like many others is being integrated into our daily lives or at the very least must start.  
The Guru Meditation app is intriguing because it begs us to question what else should we start integrating into technology.  It asks us to experience technology in many more formats than just for the use of Facebook or Twitter.  Instead it offers our already technological society one step further into the media ether.  
Educational activities, like that of the meditation activity, is slowly but surely becoming more integrated into technology each year. Students in the education system are using search engines and online forums in order to gain information that once was found through library stacks.  They have started using this technology as a way to gain information faster and relatively much more up to date. Cathy Davidson and David Goldberg's "The Future of Learning in a Digital Age" explores the ways in which institutions have to keep up with the technological society governing them.  If children's methods of learning are changing, methods of teaching need to as well. With that said, why are the education systems hesitant to embrace such use of technology?
This is due in part to deeply rooted associations and ideologies of how certain activities should be practiced.  If Guru Meditation app breaks associations it can still be productivity practiced as "original" meditation is practiced. Therefore, technological meditation does not have to be seen as a loss of something, but a gaining of something different within the experience.  Learning must do this as well by us allowing technology the ability to create a different experience.  Marc Prensky's "Digital Natives and Digital Immigrants Part I and II" shows this problem with change through the eyes of generational gaps.  Digital Natives are already soaked in the technological ether, but the Digital Immigrants are not.  This gap between generations creates a friction within the technological experience.  The main problem with this friction is that it creates a power struggle.  The Digital Immigrants are older generations who have been, up until this point, governing our Western society (our American society).  They are the ones who are in the position to teach, govern, and control, but when technology is dominating society in a type of hyper-power out of the realm of understanding of the Digital Immigrants then thats when you get resentment towards technological learning and activities like Guru Meditation.  

Part 2:

Using the iPad, many if not all apps, are a simulation of other or "original" experiences.  Target has an app for the experience of shopping, the Kindle has an app for the experience of reading, but one of the app experiences that I find the most interesting and ironic is the Facebook app.
Jean Baudrillard's article, "Simulacrea and Science Fiction" states that simulacra consists of the natural, the productive, and the simulation.  Socializing online does just this.  Facebook, as a online social network, is a simulation of the face to face experience that society attributes to childhood development on through adulthood relationships.  Therefore when this physical experience is transformed into a virtual realty it takes on different forms.  
Facebook categorizes experiences with socializing into neat outlets by searching, tagging, poking, like, and/or the coined term "friending."  So when the Facebook app is downloaded, it is taking an already simulated experience and compounding it farther into an almost hyper-simulacra - a simulacra of a simulacra.
The Facebook app is simple and clean.  It's coded with the staple light, navy blue and white Facebook colors.  It offers the same features of the Facebook website with the ability to write on friend's walls, upload pictures, and even participate in Facebook chat. So why do we need it?  It isn't necessarily more "productive" than the Facebook website.  It certainly isnt any more or less "natural" than the Facebook website.  However, from a Baudrillardian view, the Facebook app is a new simulation of a social experience we are already participating in.  Although it may not be necessary, our culture like them because these types of simulations are in fact stimulating.  So once more, we like to be stimulated by simulations.
The controversy with such simulacrea is that it started to erode the expectations of points of origin, which in this argument would be face to face socializing. Baudrillard states, "It is no longer possible to fabricate the unreal from the real...". That said, a set reality is no longer grounded, nor is it further in Baudrillard's article, necessary to maintain. What is socially appreciated is the constant influx of more stimulation.  Therefore social interaction does not exist on a stable grounding, but rather on a new expectation of constant representation and fresh simulation like the Facebook app.

Holly Combs Midterm pt. 1

After I first downloaded the Guru Meditation app, like many, I was skeptical of its effectiveness in real life meditation.  Sure, it was a cute idea, using your iPhone or iPad to help you relax.  It even made sense in some ways: people often treat their iPhones, iPads, and iPods as extensions of themselves and yet simeltaneously feel burdened by the constant technological pull that they experience when Facebook alerts and text messages beckon.  Though, while using Guru Meditation, today's consumer can meditate with his or her Apple product in hand.  This way, the technology becomes more like an extension of the human, a device required for meditation (considered by some to be something that should be a "pure" experience devoid of technological hubub, as many pointed out in class discussion), but at the same time, it can put a stop to the need to face text messages, phone calls, emails, Facebook updates, and Tweets because with Guru Meditation the medium through which we receive all of these updates is used to deliver us a break from the constant updates. When someone uses their iPhone to meditate, this means that they cannot be mediating with his/her iPhone in his/her pocket, vibrating everytime someone tries to contact him/her.  

As Katherine Hayles puts it in the passage we read from How We Became Posthuman, as humanity shifts towards what she refers to as "posthuman" there becomes "no difference betweeen bodily existence and computer simulation...no difference robot teleology and human goals." If we have truly become posthuman, then there is no difference between using the body to achieve meditation and using the Guru Meditation app.  Thus, it only makes sense that some users have come to regard their Apple products as extensions of themselves.

However, some still remain unconvinced of the magic of the app.  In the post we read by Ian Bogost he refers to apps as a little more than "sweet nothings," comparing them to Tictacs and Ke$ha.  Perhaps the best point that he makes in his post is the notion of "latertasking." Perhaps it is impossible to take apps such as Guru Meditation seriously because when using the app for meditation, one can easily snap out of meditation and log onto Twitter at his/her leisure. Though users may seem to be engrossed in Guru Meditation while staring at their iPads, Twitter, Facebook, and Angry Birds are always calling.  Perhaps the "ease and comfort" of the app defy the very essence of meditation, which is meant to help people reach a deep state of relaxation.  According to Bogost, "deep meaning seeps out of every unit [of the app]." While I feel that this accusation is unfair and slightly vague, I admit that I, too, have reservations about apps like Guru Meditation.   While I tend to agree with the statement that "the human form--including human desire and all its external representations may be changing radically and thus must be reinvisioned," I still find myself unable to take apps such as Guru Meditation seriously.  Perhaps this is because I am one of the few iPad users who feels that she would have no trouble surviving without an iPad.  I am not comfortable regarding the iPad as an extension of myself; therefore, I am not comfortable using it to meditate. 

Midterm, Chris Langer

Midterm Part one

I had never really tried the guru meditation before today and it was relieving I think is the word to use. When I closed my eyes and paid no attention to the screen or the device whatsoever, I continued with the meditation without fail, but when I began to look at the device more closely, trying to work my way through the aesthetics and what this could possibly relate to, my guru fell. I felt like Baker, when he first forgot about the medium that book was in and finally embraced the action and experience for what it was. This allowed him to penetrate the technological features of his medium, in his case, the kindle and mine, Guru Meditation, and become entangled in the world of meditation. No longer was it an IPad, but merely a medium for meditating. Just as "grey became a nice color" for Baker, I appreciated the app for what it was. Embracing the iPad into the meditation world gave new meaning to technology. Technology can penetrate the ancient field of meditation and allow one to come to terms with an inner calm.
In Benjamin's Info aesthetics, he describes new media as requiring a computer to experience it. New media was just forced upon me in the form of meditation, something that in class we have argued and struggled with as something that shouldn't be allowed within the world of technology. What Benjamin is trying to tell us is that this shift towards the informational age is inevitable and we are moving quickly towards it, if not already there. This medium of the iPad, which at any moment could pop up with a push notification from a flurry of apps, contributed to a calm, seven minutes (broken up into sets of three minutes when I got distracted by the clouds). Our new cultural age utilizes technology basically at every medium and it is impossible to escape it at times. Bogost describes the feeling of meditating upon a smart device as a "providence" of escaping the world of tweets and emails, while still utilizing the same medium. What we tend to forget as consumers is that this is not only a communication/multimedia tool, IPads can be used as educational and spiritual tools as well. The iPad can plug us in to the digital, but also sweep us away from the digital world. I'm not sure if while being in Guru Meditation all push notifications are disable, but if they are, it is the perfect sanctuary, where we feel comfortable as digital natives with this high tech device while also harkening back to a serene time of meditation. Meditation is reproducible, as a work of art, in the sense that although we lose the distance to the "original" product of meditation, a simulated copy of mediation provides us with the same comfort, just in a medium we can fully penetrate.

Part Two

Searching for an app to write about, I clicked upon Google Earth. At first I saw the whole world from space, then slowly my world spun as the app was zeroing in on the last place I was exploring. It turned out to be my home in Saint Louis, with everything serene and beautiful. One odd feature though: my car was parked outside of it, the same car that is parked in the Freret parking garage right now.
Google earth prides itself on being a real simulation of every part of the world right now at this instant.

I'll try to take on Baudrillard with this app. He argues that " it is no longer possible to fabricate the real from the unreal." Other sites I would take as real, not simulated fabrications, because Google Earth promises the "real." But what I see is pure simulation, pure fabrication based upon the real, a hyper reality where imagination is gone. It is a "simulacra of simulation, founded on information" from Google satellites. There is no imaginary anymore. The distance between imagination and the real has been abolished and only the simulation of the real remains.

Baudrillard speaks of science fiction as dead, without an imaginary, which now must focus on revitalizing the "so called real world" that we think we experience. All of these apps and devices are part of this experiment. Google earth attempts to bring us back to what it was like to discover a new place, find a new world, and be truly inspired by the awe of it. But what it is really doing is simulating what we already know as unreal, the map. Google earth took the second order of simulacra, the productivist map, which was mass produced through industrial society in order to bring the real world to the people, and manipulate it into a hyper real idea, where we can now "re discover" the world, as if we are the true explorers. We can see what explorers see by participating in these " fragments of universal simulation that have become for us the so called real world." We are always "already in this other world," stuck within the simulation. We cannot escape the four month old satellite images of Google, we are forced to accept it as real. Up till now, this is as close to a true view of the world our IPad can give us.
Baudrillard states that "only the last order (the operational) can truly interest us." Maps do not interest our generation, we want the real, or the simulation of that real, the hyper real. This science fiction is the only thing that draws us in, because we no longer have the imagination, we merely want to see what used to be the real. We want Google to bring us back to reality, but all it can offer is the hyper reality of the third order simulacra.