Because of this love for books, I got a summer job at the Tulane Barnes and Nobel. I spent first two months of my summer unpacking boxes filled with books, putting books on shelves, stickering them, and rearranging them ever so often. I have read the back of the majority of the books in the store at this point.
Maybe a month into my working at B&N, my manager, Peggy, who has spent more than half of her life working with books, told me that we would soon be getting Nooks, the eReader for B&N, into our store. Everyone would have to learn how to use them and sell them. Peggy seemed irritated about this. At around the same time, she told me that the regional manager had decided to condense the book section of the store and replace it with clothing once the Nook got in. Peggy and I spent about two weeks sorting through books, making big piles on the floor of books that would have to be returned to make way for the clothing expansion. Once we were done, the other managers rearranged the store so that clothing took up about 2/3 of the lower level and books were left the remaining third. It had been split almost 50/50 before.
The day that the Nook display went up, there were lots of jokes about books becoming obsolete and the clothing section's slow takeover of the college book store. I think that Peggy and I shared the same resentment towards the eReader because of this. After spending some time learning about all of the Nook's handy features, however, I began to develop mixed feelings about the device.
On one hand, I feel like a traitor working at a book store and selling this product that could very well make books obsolete. On the other hand, I have to sell this eReader to keep my job because that's what Barnes and Nobel feels like having its employees do. On another hand, I'm an English major with a Spanish minor, and the Nook has really awesome stuff that could help me out with that like free classic literature and the ability to look up unfamiliar words and phrases, even Spanish words and phrases. Also, as a student, an eReader could be really helpful because textbooks will probably be available on eReaders, hopefully for a lower cost than the non-digital versions, and I won't have to carry giant books like the complete works of George Orwell around with me all day a couple days a week. (Thanks, Dr. Cotton!) And then on another hand, I just love books, and even though these eReaders let you digitally highlight and type notes, it's not at satisfying or as simple as putting pen to paper in a real book. On some other hand, a customer was telling me that when books became available to read online and on iPods and things like that, book sales actually increased and the new technology actually just served to promote reading in general. We both hoped that eReaders would do something similar. I'm up to like five on the other hands, and I don't even have that many hands. In short, I don't know how to feel about eReaders, but it's something that I've been thinking about a lot and will continue to think about. I have already witnessed some ways that the eReaders have changed things, and I will be interested to see what else comes of these devices.
This is an astute reflection on the geometry of e-reading. You do such a good job of pointing out its many angles, and I particularly like your use of "on the one hand, on the other hand"—culminating in this remark: "I'm up to like five on the other hands, and I don't even have that many hands." This statement has a lot of theoretical value. Indeed, matters of digital media take us into the realm of the post-human, where having only two hands—or only seeing two sides of one issue—is never enough. Rather, these sorts of issues demand that we think multiply and flexibly about the terms in question. What is a 'real' book? Is the meaning of 'reading' changing? How do digital media practices change the way we think about the physical weight of objects in our hands? What do clothing sales have to do with books? All of these questions, and more, fall under the rubric of our course...which will commence in just a few weeks! Thanks for this excellent post.
ReplyDelete